Get new listings emailed daily! JOIN SIGN IN
Jenny McNeil
President's Club 2023
REALTOR®, GRI
Broker Associate
2008 Realtor of the Year
(574) 532-4999
VCard Icon 

Customer Reviews

testimonial quote

Jenny is so likeable and personable. We had 3 other realtors access our property and by far Jenny was the best choice. She believed she could sell it and pointed out the good points of the home. We signed with her late on a Monday. She posted the next morning. We had 4 showings and an offer that day. She had an excellent plan laid out to sell the home. It went like clockwork. Without a doubt I will use Jenny again. She will be recommended every chance I get.

Cindy Brehmer, South Bend, IN | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Beth, Mishawaka | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Jenny was friendly, knowledgeable and made it very stress free for my mom!!

Beth, Mishawaka | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Jo, Mishawaka, IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

She was understanding about overall square footage, and more importantly location.

Jo, Mishawaka, IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

PAT TASSELL, MISHAWAKA, IN 46544 | Home Seller
testimonial quote

WE ARE IN THE RENTAL BUSINESS AND WE HAVE PURCHASED AND SOLD MANY PROPERTIES OVER THE YEARS. JENNY IS GREAT.

PAT TASSELL, MISHAWAKA, IN 46544 | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Lisa Bodey, Osceola, IN | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Jenny McNeil was a pleasure to work with and was always very responsive answering our questions via emails, texts and phone calls. Her confidence and knowledge of the market eased our mind throughout the process. We were at a critical point of needing to sell the house due to family circumstances, so we appreciated the tips and support on how to get the house ready for showing. She was always very professional, explained each step along the way and made sure we met all critical deadlines. We would definitely recommend Jenny to potential clients and appreciated working with such a reputable company as Cressy & Everett.

Lisa Bodey, Osceola, IN | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Jenny was professional yet approachable, understanding of my needs and misgivings. Jenny encouraged me to look for "the one" and when I did she worked like a pro to get me everything I needed. Funny, charming and yet totally knowledgeable.

Sally Sorberg, Osceola Indiana | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

The home we sold had been our parents and the house we kids grew up in. Jenny McNeil was sensitive to this as we went through the process of preparing for the sale. Her kindness and professionalism made the sale easier to handle when we got to the table. My brother, living out of town was able to close there and I in town. The paperwork was handled flawlessly. I would recommend Jenny to anyone.

Norma Woodruff, Mishawaka, Indiana | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Edith, Mishawaka | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Excellent agent, very professional, great to work with.

Edith, Mishawaka | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Mary Ann Myers, South Bend | Home Seller
testimonial quote

We have bought and sold multiple homes through Jenny. I wouldn't consider anyone else. We sold our mom's house and she knew how difficult it was and was caring and compassionate. I was texting Jenny on weekends, evenings, and even on vacation, and she got back to me within minutes. I highly recommend her.

Mary Ann Myers, South Bend | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Will Misner, South Bend | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Jenny was extremely professional is all aspects of the purchase of our home at 1428 E Jefferson. I would recommend her without any reservation.

Will Misner, South Bend | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Deborah Robinson | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Professional yet personable, Patient yet persistent, trustworthy and timely. Jenny McNeil is a great example of what a realtor should be like.

Deborah Robinson | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Janis Mishawaka | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Jenny did everything well. I have recommended Jenny in the past and would not hesitate to do so again.

Janis Mishawaka | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Pat Tassell | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Jenny is a very experienced realtor. She sold my house, my friends house, and several of my rental properties. She has great advice on how to make a property sell for more. I will always recommend Jenny to anyone I know that wants to sell a property.

Pat Tassell | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Dave Weber. Mishawaka, Indiana | Home Seller
testimonial quote

I enjoyed the experience very much! Meeting at the office was fast and she was very helpful in sorting through the offers! We thank Jenny for a job well done! We are "SOLD" on Jenny! Jenny is The Mishawaka Realtor! She knows the market and clients looking to purchase in Mishawaka! She has the contacts needed to get a quick sale. More importantly, she has very wonderful "people skills!" She makes sellers and buyers very comfortable and she knows the answers! She was very accessible when I needed answers! The purchase was extremely easy for us! She led us through the process every step of the way! The house was listed, had 10 showings, 7 offers, and was sold in 3 days! I will definitely recommend Jenny to anyone needing a realtor! We live in Mishawaka and she will be our realtor when we sell our home! We can not thank Jenny enough for the comp. analysis and listing price suggestion! Both were right on the money! I enjoyed the experience very much! Meeting at the office was fast and she was very helpful in sorting through the offers! We thank Jenny for a job well done! We are "SOLD" on Jenny!

Dave Weber. Mishawaka, Indiana | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Dante DelPrete, Mishawaka | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Jenny was extremely patient with me and understood my needs entirely. She was willing to spend extra time with me to ensure I understood every aspect of the transaction.

Dante DelPrete, Mishawaka | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Jenni McNeil proved herself to be the epitome of why you choose a Realtor. She has the expertise you can only pray for. She knew every aspect of the market inside and out.There was a slight hiccup during the process, which made me apprehensive as I am a first time seller. She assured me not to worry and to trust her. Can I just say Im so glad we did!! She had the issue resolved within a matter of days and got almost exactly what she said we would. PLUS SOME!!! She was also able to help a first time buyer FINALLY get a home in THIS market. WIN/WIN for everyone. We simply could not have asked for more from her. It was seamless from start to finish.

Rich and Lauri Laws | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Dave and Doreen Behnke | Home Seller
testimonial quote

We were very pleased with everything that Jenny did helping us sell our house! She is a true professional!

Dave and Doreen Behnke | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Beth Blair-Kelley Mishawaka, IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Amazing, personal, thorough and knowledgeable service. Jenny is very highly regarded in this area, and now we know why! Wonderful personality and also just fun to work with. Always available when you have questions

Beth Blair-Kelley Mishawaka, IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Kenneth, Mishawaka | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Jenny is amazing. We relocated from South Dakota. Jenny is very professional with her Job. She is truly for the buyers and it just out here to collect a check. She has a passion and heart for this. Jenny is like family to My wife and 3 young boys.

Kenneth, Mishawaka | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Timothy Terpening, Lakeville | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Jenny is top notch. Her word is gold. We have a lot of confidence in her knowledge and ability. And her personality cannot be beat.

Timothy Terpening, Lakeville | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Jenny was extremely knowledgeable about the market and provided helpful insight into ways to enhance the sale.

David Hoeferkamp | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Lea Ann Sterling, Sault Ste Marie | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Joyful Jenny! Very professional in every way. Can do attitude. Problem solver. We are very happy with Jenny in an otherwise sad situation selling the home of our deceased parents.

Lea Ann Sterling, Sault Ste Marie | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Veneranda Bogaert now of Elkhart IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Jenny is the most personable, considerate and knowledgeable of the market. She keeps your most important needs foremost. Even if you don't. The time you spend together going from place to place is comfortable. She even will stop and get a water, and offer one she will provide next time. She has acquired new skills in her many years in the busy. Our last purchase in Indiana was thru Jenny McNeil. We lived there for 25 years. Now our son and his family live there. Once I wanted to send an email, just so I wouldn't forget it. It was very late in the evening. She called me right away. I was impressed. I have gone in great details already. The most impressive compliment would be, she has YOUR interests as her number one priority. Went to the office once (Jenny was giving a class). I needed a copy of a document for the BMV. A gentleman was kind enough to do so. My gratitude is great and speaks highly on the company.

Veneranda Bogaert now of Elkhart IN | Home Buyer
testimonial quote

Matt Misner, South Bend, IN | Home Seller
testimonial quote

The entire experience went well and without any glitches. I would recommend this company and Jenny McNeil to anyone buying a home in the South Bend region.

Matt Misner, South Bend, IN | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Karen Muller, Sylvania, OH | Home Seller
testimonial quote

I live out of state and was handling the sale of my mother's house. Jenny made the entire process easier for me. I commend her knowledge in guiding me through the process as well as the necessary documents, her accessibility, and her prompt communications. As I was not familiar with companies needed to assist in repair work following inspection, she was extremely helpful in putting me in contact with the appropriate tradespeople. I don't know how I would have managed without her. She has my gratitude.

Karen Muller, Sylvania, OH | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Janet Roberts | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Very responsive to questions and needs House sold in ONE day, great job coordinating viewings , keeping me posted, and assisting with accepting offers to choose Available for questions with long working hours, polite with answers. She was “There for me and my personal interests “! Highly recommend her 40+ years of experience!

Janet Roberts | Home Seller
testimonial quote

Elkhart Resident | Home Seller
testimonial quote

From a sellers perspective a sale of a home is always complicated by pricing, items to fix and other unplanned or unexpected occurrences that need to be addressed. Jenny handled this all superbly, was very readily available and very conscientious.

Elkhart Resident | Home Seller
testimonial quote

My wife and I have purchased other homes throughout the US and can honestly say that Jenny is by far the BEST realtor we have ever had. She is warm, personable, and flat out knows what she is doing. I wouldn't trade her for anyone else. She is truly a blessing in this field and to our family. There are only a few people that I can honestly say are not simply people that I work with but are "friends" as well. Jenny is one to the Misner family whole-heartedly. Thanks Jenny for all that you do. Matt Misner

Matt Misner, South Bend, IN | Home Buyer
Note: a subscription to the Do Not Call list does not apply when requesting information from our company.

Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 06/01/2026. The listing information on this page last changed on 06/01/2026. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Delta Media Group MLS (last updated Mon 06/01/2026 4:59:23 AM EST) or MichRic (Michigan Regional Information Center) (last updated Sun 05/31/2026 11:17:30 PM EST) or NIRA MLS (last updated Sun 05/31/2026 11:04:46 PM EST) or IRMLS (last updated Sun 05/31/2026 11:11:58 PM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Cressy & Everett Real Estate may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility

Agency License Information: Cressy & Everett Real Estate is licensed in the states of Indiana and Michigan.



Agent License Information: Jenny McNeil is licensed to sell real estate in the state of Indiana.

Login to My Homefinder

Pixel